You may have heard that a certain rate of EVV manual edits triggers an audit in Colorado. HCPF has never published one. What it has published is two separate checks, a set of targets, and since 2026 a plain list of what its analysts look for before they contact an agency.
Two separate checks
Before payment: a matching EVV record. Since February 1, 2022, every claim for an EVV-required service goes through a pre-payment check, and a claim without the EVV record it needs denies. On the remittance it shows as EOB 3054, "EVV Record Required and Not Found".
After payment: the manual-edit review. HCPF defines a threshold as the acceptable limit of modified and manual EVV records, as a percent of paid claims each month. Its EVV Program Manual (page last updated October 26, 2026) then says: "At this time CMS does not have thresholds set for manual or modified entries and HCPF does not currently have thresholds on how many EVV records are manually entered or modified."
So manual and edited records do not stop a claim from paying. They are reviewed after payment, and the manual warns that exceeding thresholds "persistently and intentionally" could lead to an HCPF audit. One more rule from the same section: if you edit an EVV record that already matched a paid claim, re-bill that claim so it still matches.
What HCPF publishes as targets
With no official threshold, these are the numbers HCPF has put its name to, as goals:
- Fewer than 10% of visits as manual entries. The August 2025 EVV newsletter: "Aim for less than 10% of total visits to be manual entries." A high volume, it adds, may point to training or system issues.
- 85% or more auto-verified, fewer than 2% incomplete. HCPF's Unmodified EVV Reporting Fact Sheet (January 2026) gives these as examples of simple goals.
The outreach letters and what they flag
HCPF now compares EVV data with claims, and agencies its analysis flags receive targeted EVV reports. The May 2026 and July 2026 EVV newsletters name what it looks for:
- EVV minutes that do not match the units billed. HCPF calls these unjustified payments and says they "may be subject to review and/or recovery". Billed units should match the time EVV verified.
- A high volume of manual entries, or repeated use of a single reason code. HCPF watches reason code use "through routine analytics".
- Caregiver mismatch. The caregiver on the EVV record must be the caregiver on the timesheet for each date of service. When a shift is covered or swapped, update both.
- Span billing without daily EVV. A claim may cover a range of dates, but EVV applies to each visit, so every day services were delivered needs a complete EVV record.
Reason codes and notes that hold up
A reason code explains why an EVV record was entered or changed: a missed clock-in or out, a service correction, a location problem. HCPF's May 2026 newsletter sets the rules:
- Pick the code that fits this visit. Codes "should not be applied uniformly across multiple visits without validation".
- Write what happened. Notes should describe the situation and "should not be overwritten or replaced with standardized language".
- Alternate locations are fine. The August 2025 newsletter says there are no daily limits on using alternate locations; what matters is a clear note each time.
Reconcile timesheets with EVV before you bill, and note any difference you keep.
Exemptions
Some services do not need EVV when a documented live-in caregiver gives them: a caregiver who permanently lives in the same home as the client. Each claim line a live-in caregiver delivered is marked as such (Place of Service 99 on the professional claim form most agencies use), and HCPF treats that mark as a claim of live-in status, so the proof has to be in your files.
- The form. Use HCPF's EVV Exemption Form (February 2025) and keep it, with the supporting documents, for every live-in caregiver and the dates they cover.
- Pre-approval. An extenuating-circumstance live-in exemption and a reasonable modification under the Americans with Disabilities Act both need HCPF's approval before you use them.
- The portal is paused. Since November 2025, HCPF has paused submitting live-in exemptions through the Provider Web Portal. Keep the documentation in your own records until HCPF says otherwise.
A claim billed as exempt without the documentation behind it remains subject to denial, recoupment or audit findings.
Checking your own numbers in Sandata
In December 2025 HCPF retired the EVV Performance Report Cards. Sandata's reports screen now gives providers three reports:
- Auto Verification Summary: how many visits were auto-verified, manually verified or incomplete.
- Auto Verification Detail: each visit, with why it did not auto-verify.
- EVV Compliance Report: scheduled and actual times by caregiver, with any adjusted times.
A visit counts as manually verified if a call was a manual call, its times were adjusted, or it has updates. HCPF's own monthly Unmodified Performance Reports are built from paid claims, so they will be close to Sandata's figures but not identical.
A monthly check for your agency:
- Run the Auto Verification Summary for last month and write down the manual, auto-verified and incomplete percentages.
- Compare them with the targets: fewer than 10% manual entries, 85% or more auto-verified, fewer than 2% incomplete.
- Sort the manual visits by caregiver. If a few names explain most of them, train those caregivers first.
- Sort by reason code. If one code dominates, check that each use fits its visit.
- Compare EVV minutes with units billed for each client, and fix the gap before you bill.